Public broker or notary? Differences and which one to go to
Not sure whether your matter is handled by a broker or a notary? Both grant public faith and hold the same rank. The difference lies in the matters each one handles.
Two public officers for different matters
The State delegates public faith to different professionals. The notary and the public broker are two of them. Neither is above the other: they are distinct figures, created for distinct matters, and what separates them is not hierarchy but jurisdiction.
Where each figure comes from
The notary is an institution rooted in civil law, under local jurisdiction. Each state has its own law: in Mexico City, the Notarial Law for Mexico City. The license is granted by the state government and the notary practices within it.
The public broker is under federal jurisdiction. It is governed by the Federal Public Broker Law, published in 1992, and its regulations. The license is granted by the Ministry of Economy, which also supervises practice. The broker is, by legal definition, a trade auxiliary.
Everything else follows from this: the notary has general jurisdiction; the broker has commercial jurisdiction.
Same value, different name
The notary records in their protocol and authorizes public deeds for legal acts, and notarial certificates for facts. They issue certified copies from these.
The public broker records in their Registry Book and authorizes policies for commercial contracts, agreements, and legal acts, and certificates for commercial facts and document certifications. They issue certified copies from these.
Two different names for the same effect: both are public instruments and both provide full proof. A company constituted by policy before a public broker and one constituted by deed before a notary are registered equally in the Public Commercial Registry and are worth exactly the same.
Comparison
What each one handles
| Aspect | Public broker | Notary |
|---|---|---|
| Governing law | Federal Public Broker Law. Licensing and supervision by the Ministry of Economy. | Notarial law of each state. In Mexico City, the Notarial Law for Mexico City. |
| Subject matter | Exclusively commercial. | Civil and commercial. |
| Instrument | Policy and certificate, recorded in the Registry Book. Issues certified copies. | Deed and certificate, recorded in the protocol. Issues certified copies. |
| Incorporation of commercial companies | Competent. The instrument is the policy, registered in the Public Commercial Registry.→ | Competent. The instrument is the public deed, registered in the Public Commercial Registry. |
| Assemblies, capital increases, merger, split | Competent. This is the broker's own domain.→ | Competent. |
| Commercial contracts and agreements | Competent, unless the act involves real estate. | Competent. |
| Real estate operations | Does not intervene. The law expressly excludes it. | Exclusive jurisdiction. The required official for transferring real estate ownership. |
| Wills, estates, and civil status acts | Does not intervene. Proper domain of notarial practice. | Exclusive jurisdiction. |
| Statement of facts | Certification of facts: only commercial facts, such as the use of a trademark or the delivery of goods. · General facts. | Of facts in general. |
| Document certification and signature ratification | Competent in commercial matters. | Competent. |
| Valuation | Expert appraiser by express provision of their law: goods, services, rights and obligations, including intangibles and going concerns.→ | Not a function their law attributes to them. |
| Commercial mediation and arbitration | Express function of their law: mediation agent and arbitrator in commercial disputes.→ | Not a function of their own law. May perform it if certified under alternative justice legislation. |
Frequent questions
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a public broker and a notary?
The matters each one handles. The broker handles only commercial matters. The notary handles civil and commercial matters. The broker signs pólizas and minutes in his register book; the notary signs deeds and minutes in his protocol.
Can a public broker record the incorporation of my company?
Yes. It is one of the broker's own acts. The póliza is registered with the Public Commercial Registry just like a deed, and it has the same value.
When should I go to a notary?
In three cases: operations involving real estate; wills, inheritances and other civil or family matters; and powers granted by a company. Powers must be protocolized before a notary, under Article 10 of the General Law of Commercial Companies.
Does a póliza before a public broker carry the same value as a notary deed?
Yes. Both are public instruments and constitute full evidence; testimonies (certified copies) are issued from either with the same legal effect.
Who should I contact for a commercial contract?
Before either of them, unless the contract concerns real estate. In that case it is the notary's turn. The broker specializes in commercial matters.
Are you going to incorporate a company?
Message me on WhatsApp with who the partners will be, whether any of them is a foreigner and what the company will do. I reply the same business day with the type of company that fits, the documents I need and the cost in writing. That first consultation does not The client is bound to:.
Consult without obligation